HOA architectural review process and application checklist
Key takeaways
- Architectural review checks a homeowner's proposed exterior change against the declaration and design guidelines before work starts. The committee can review only what those documents give it power to review.
- Ask for a complete packet: the form, a site plan, drawings or product specifications, colors and materials, and contractor details. Date the application the day it arrives.
- Decide at a meeting with a quorum, record each member's vote in the minutes, and send a written decision that names the rule applied and, for a denial, what would fix the problem.
- Check your declaration for a response deadline. If it says a missed deadline counts as approval, a late answer can approve the project by default.
- State law adds rules in some places. Texas gives a denied owner a board hearing in the associations its statute covers. California gives reconsideration by the board unless the board made the decision itself at a properly held board meeting. Florida requires a denial to name the rule and the part of the project that does not conform.
An HOA architectural review is how an association approves or denies a homeowner's change to the outside of a home or lot, such as a fence, a shed, a new roof color or an addition. The owner applies, the architectural review committee compares the request with the written standards, and the committee answers in writing. This guide is for the committee members and directors who run that process.
Two related jobs have their own guides. Enforcement after unapproved work is in the covenant enforcement guide, and meeting procedure in general is in how to run an HOA board meeting.
This guide is general information, not legal advice. The statutes cited were read on November 13, 2026. Your governing documents and state law decide how review works in your association, and Florida condominiums follow chapter 718 rather than the HOA chapter cited here. Ask your association's attorney before you deny an application or rely on a missed deadline.
Where does the committee's power come from?
Start with the declaration, the recorded set of covenants, conditions and restrictions that many owners call the CC&Rs. If it requires approval before exterior work, it also says who gives that approval: a committee, or the board itself. The design guidelines hold the detailed standards, such as approved colors, materials and fence heights.
The committee can review only what those documents give it power to review, and some states say so in statute. In Florida, review of plans and enforcement of appearance standards are allowed only to the extent the declaration, or published guidelines it authorizes, states that authority or reasonably implies it, and the association and its committee must apply and enforce those standards reasonably and equitably on all parcel owners (section 720.3035(1)(a)). Where the governing documents require approval, California requires each decision to be made in good faith and not be unreasonable, arbitrary or capricious (Civil Code section 4765(a)(2)). Arizona says approval of a construction project's designs and plans shall not be unreasonably withheld, whatever the community documents say (section 33-1817(B)(3)).
Florida also limits review of one kind of project. Every HOA there must adopt hurricane protection specifications through its board or architectural committee, and the board or committee may not deny an application for hurricane protection that conforms to them (section 720.3035(6)).
Who should sit on the committee?
Your bylaws or declaration set the committee's size, who appoints the members and how long they serve. Staggered terms keep the whole committee from turning over at once. If the documents say nothing about term limits, write the board's practice down, so a new member knows when their seat ends.
State law can override the documents, and two states point in opposite directions. Texas sets rules for associations of more than 40 lots. They do not apply during a development period, or while the declarant appoints most of the architectural review authority, otherwise controls its appointment, or can veto or change its decisions (Property Code section 209.00505(b)). Where they apply, the association must send members a notice asking for volunteers at least 10 days before it fills a seat, with a reply deadline at least 10 days after the notice. Only people who replied by that deadline may be appointed or elected, and a current director, a director's spouse or anyone living in a director's household may not serve. If a seat is still empty after every eligible volunteer who replied has been appointed, the association may fill it with anyone, a director included (sections 209.00506 and 209.00507). In Arizona, the design review or architectural committee must include at least one director, who chairs it (section 33-1817(B)(1)).
Keep the current members' names and term dates with the board's other officer records.
What should the application include?
A complete application lets the committee compare the request with the written standards without chasing the owner for a missing page. One checklist can cover the form and the attachments.
Application checklist
- Owner name, lot number, property address, phone and email
- A description of the work, with planned start and finish dates
- Contractor name, license number and contact details, if the owner hires one, plus a certificate of insurance if your guidelines ask for it
- Estimated project cost
- A site plan or plat showing where the work sits on the lot and how far it is from each lot line
- Dimensioned drawings or manufacturer specifications for anything built or installed
- Colors and materials, with physical samples where your guidelines ask for them
- A landscaping plan for any change to grading or plantings
- The owner's signature, agreeing to follow the governing documents and to get any permit the local government requires
- The fee, if your documents set one
Add two lines for the committee to fill in: the date received and an application number. The date starts any deadline your documents set, and the number ties the letter, the minutes and the photos to one file.
In Florida, an association or committee may not require a government building permit before it will review the plans (section 720.3035(1)(c)).
How should the committee review an application?
Measure the request against the written standards
Compare the proposal with the design guidelines line by line. If a guideline says a fence may not exceed six feet, a fence of five feet ten inches passes whether or not members like the style. Look at the lot if the request needs it, note what is there today, and keep the notes and dated photos with the application.
Treat like requests alike. Before deciding, look up how the committee handled the last similar request. If this one will come out differently, write down why.
Decide at a meeting and record the vote
Your bylaws or the committee's charter set the quorum and the vote needed to decide. Confirm attendance before the vote, vote on a motion, and record each member's vote in the minutes. A decision made without the required quorum may not stand.
In a Florida HOA, a body with the power to approve or disapprove architectural decisions on a specific owner's parcel follows the same open meeting rules as the board (section 720.303(2)(a)). Under that subsection a meeting happens whenever a quorum gathers to conduct association business, so a quorum of the committee walking a lot together may be a meeting. The same subsection bars directors from casting a vote on association business by email and extends its provisions to the committee's meetings, so decide applications at a meeting, not by email. Committee members may not vote by proxy or by secret ballot (section 720.303(2)(c)3). Notice naming the agenda items generally has to be posted conspicuously in the community at least 48 hours ahead, or mailed or delivered to each member at least 7 days ahead (section 720.303(2)(c)1). The Florida board meeting guide covers those rules.
What should the decision letter say?
Send every decision in writing, within the deadline your documents set. The letter gives the application number, the guideline sections applied, the decision (approval, approval with conditions or denial), any conditions in full, and how to ask for reconsideration or appeal.
A denial should name the rule and say what would fix the problem. Grounds for a denial include a project that breaks a setback, height or lot coverage rule, colors or materials outside the approved list, and a missing site plan or drawing. A denial that names both the rule and the fix might read:
Denied under design guidelines section 4.2, which requires a fence to stand at least 20 feet from the rear lot line. Approval is available if the fence is moved at least 20 feet from that line.
A reason like "not in keeping with the community" gives the owner nothing to fix and invites an argument.
Some states set what the letter must contain:
- In Florida, a denial must state in writing the specific rule or covenant the association relied on and the specific part of the project that does not conform (section 720.3035(4)(a)). An owner whose architectural rights the association or committee unreasonably, knowingly and willfully infringes can recover damages, costs and reasonable attorney fees (section 720.3035(4)(b)).
- In Texas, in the associations the statute covers, the denial goes by certified mail, hand delivery or electronic delivery. It describes the basis in reasonable detail, lists any changes required for approval, and tells the owner they may request a board hearing on or before the 30th day after the notice was mailed (section 209.00505(d)).
- In California, every decision is in writing, and a disapproval explains why and describes how to ask the board to reconsider (Civil Code section 4765(a)(4)).
What if someone already said yes out loud?
A verbal yes is hard to prove for either side. If your documents require written approval, a spoken OK may not bind the association, and in California every decision on a change that needs approval has to be in writing. If a member did give an informal yes, put the application on the next properly noticed agenda, decide it, and file the written decision with the application.
How long does the committee have to decide?
Your declaration or design guidelines may set a deadline for a decision. Note what starts the clock, such as receipt of a complete application. Then read what happens if the committee misses it. The clause may treat a missed deadline as approval, which is called deemed approval, or as a denial, or it may not say. Check also whether asking the owner for more information pauses the clock. If the wording is unclear, ask counsel before relying on it either way.
California requires the association's written review procedure to set prompt deadlines and to state the maximum time for a response to an application or a request for reconsideration (Civil Code section 4765(a)(1)). It also requires a yearly notice telling members which changes need approval, with a copy of that procedure (section 4765(c)).
The Texas, Florida, California and Arizona sections cited in this guide set no general deadline for ordinary architectural decisions. Some state laws set time limits for particular projects. Two examples:
- In Maryland, an application to install electric vehicle charging equipment in an owner's own parking space counts as approved if the HOA does not deny it in writing within 60 days after receiving it, unless a reasonable request for more information caused the delay (Real Property section 11B-111.8(c)).
- In California, a body reviewing an application to rebuild a home destroyed or damaged in a disaster, in substantially the same form, has 30 calendar days to say whether the application is complete. If it misses that date, the application counts as complete, and the body then has 45 calendar days to approve it or return written comments (Civil Code section 4766).
Whatever sets the deadline, put it on the calendar the day the complete application arrives, and review pending applications at every meeting so none lapses quietly.
Can the owner appeal a denial?
That depends on your documents and your state.
In Texas, in the associations the statute covers, the owner can ask the board for a hearing. The board holds it within 30 days of the request and tells the owner the date, time and place at least 10 days ahead. Either side can ask for a postponement of up to 10 days, either side may make an audio recording, and the board can affirm, modify or reverse the decision (section 209.00505(d) to (i)). The appeal must be heard in an open meeting with notice to owners (section 209.0051(h)(7)).
In California, an owner whose change is disapproved is entitled to reconsideration by the board at an open meeting. The exception is a decision the board itself made, or a body with the same membership, at a meeting that met the board meeting rules (Civil Code section 4765(a)(5)).
The Florida and Arizona sections cited here set no appeal procedure, so look to your documents. Wherever the appeal goes, the owner should bring the application number, the section cited in the denial and any revised plan.
What if the owner started work without approval?
If your declaration requires approval before work starts, starting without it is usually a violation, even when the project would have passed review. The committee can still review an application after the fact and judge the project against the same standards as any other. The board then decides what enforcement, if any, follows. Notices, hearings and fines have their own rules, covered step by step in the covenant enforcement guide. Handle each case the way the last comparable one was handled, so no owner can point to a neighbor who was let off.
Where should the records live?
Keep one file per application, named by address and date. It holds the application and attachments, the site notes and photos, the minutes excerpt with the vote, and the decision letter. Store it where the next committee can find it, not in one volunteer's personal inbox, because the next request on that street will be measured against what this committee approved.
Where does One Group Central fit?
One Group Central is a private, invite-only member portal with documents, announcements, chat, events, polls, a member directory and voting. It does not run the application workflow: there is no application form, tracking number or status screen, and homeowners cannot upload files to the document library. What a committee can do with it:
- Publish the design guidelines and the blank form in the document library. While the library has no categories yet, "Start from a template" offers an HOA or condo association set that includes Architectural Requests and Forms. The "Send announcement to members" switch tells owners when a new version goes up. The edit dialog cannot replace a file, so post a revised form as a new document.
- Put the committee in a member group. Every group gets its own chat channel, and documents and calendar events can be targeted at the group, which keeps application packets with the committee. The portal's owner and admin accounts can see every document, so give admin rights only to people entitled to see homeowners' plans.
- If your association leaves direct messages on, a homeowner can send the completed form, photos and drawings to the committee chair or an admin in a chat direct message. An admin with the Upload permission then files the packet under Architectural Requests, targeted at the committee group.
- Put each decision deadline on the calendar as an event for the committee group, with an alert up to a week before.
Owner votes, when your documents call for them, run in the same app: ballots are encrypted, admins see totals only, and each voter gets a receipt they can check. That also means a portal election cannot show how each committee member voted, so the committee's own vote belongs in its minutes.
Monthly plans cost $49 to $199 per organization, with member limits from 100 to 1,000 accounts (plans and limits). Count the people who need accounts, not homes, since co-owners may need separate logins. The 60-day trial covers up to 25 people, including you and your admins, with no credit card, and open invitations reserve seats.
If you want the application itself tracked in software, GatherAMS lists architectural review (ARC) requests as a live feature on its features page, checked November 13, 2026. The GatherAMS comparison covers the other differences.
Glossary
- Approval with conditions
- A yes that depends on changes, such as a different color or a moved fence. The decision letter states each condition in full.
- Architectural review committee
- The committee or other body your governing documents authorize to approve or deny exterior changes. Some documents call it a design review committee, and the Texas statute calls it the architectural review authority. In some associations the board reviews applications itself.
- Declarant
- The person or company, usually the developer, that created the community and recorded the declaration. A declaration can reserve rights to the declarant for a time, such as appointing the architectural committee.
- Declaration
- The recorded document of covenants, conditions and restrictions, often called the CC&Rs, that binds the lots in the community. When it requires approval for exterior changes, it is the source of the committee's power.
- Deemed approval
- A rule in the governing documents or a statute under which an application counts as approved if no decision arrives by the deadline.
- Design guidelines
- The written standards the committee measures applications against, such as approved colors, materials and fence heights. Check the declaration for who may adopt or change them.
- Development period
- A period stated in the declaration during which the declarant keeps the right to develop, build and market the community, or to direct its size, shape and makeup. Texas defines it this way in Property Code section 209.002.
- Governing documents
- The declaration, articles of incorporation, bylaws, design guidelines and rules that together set how the association runs and what owners may do.
- Lot coverage
- The share of a lot's area covered by buildings and other structures. A lot coverage rule caps that share.
- Plat
- A recorded map of the subdivision that shows each lot's boundaries.
- Quorum
- The number of committee members who must be present for the committee to act. Your bylaws or the committee's charter set it.
- Setback
- The minimum distance a structure must keep from a lot line, street or other boundary.
Keep the committee's files and deadlines in one place
One Group Central keeps documents, announcements, chat and the calendar in one private portal, with files you can target at a committee group. Ballots are encrypted, admins see totals only, and each voter gets a receipt they can check.
Start your free 60 day trialFree for 60 days with up to 25 people. No credit card.